Un curioso caso de retroalimentación informativa

Benjamín Montesinos

En algunos campos científicos, por ejemplo en medicina, y dada la inmensa cantidad de material científico que se publica a diario, algunos investigadores se enteran del trabajo de sus colegas a través de los medios de comunicación. En un artículo titulado «El Dr. Hwang y el clon que nunca existió» de Vladimir de Semir y Gemma Revuelta publicado en la revista Quark, los autores describen un curioso episodio de retroalimentación entre medios de comunicación y revistas científicas.

En 1991 apareció en el New England Journal of Medicine un interesante estudio acerca del impacto de las noticias que aparecen en los medios de comunicación, referidas a ciencia, sobre los propios científicos.

Con motivo de una huelga en The New York Times, este periódico estuvo tres meses sin salir a la calle. La huelga fue bastante particular, porque los redactores siguieron trabajando como de costumbre, cada sección con su trabajo particular, acudiendo a ruedas de prensa o, en el caso de los encargados de la sección de ciencia, consultando revistas científicas. La única diferencia es que el diario no salía a la calle, aunque el número de cada día quedaba compuesto.

Unos años más tarde, un grupo de investigadores buscó entre esas páginas no publicadas cuáles eran las noticias que se habían basado en artículos de revistas científicas médicas, y siguieron la pista contando cuántas citas habían recibido esos artículos en otros trabajos científicos, es decir, cuál había sido su nivel de impacto dentro de la comunidad científica.

Estos investigadores compararon estos datos con los que se referían a artículos mencionados en el mismo diario pero en un periodo en el que The New York Times había llegado a los lectores con normalidad. En ese caso los científicos habían tenido oportunidad de leer el diario. El resultado fue que los artículos mencionados en The New York Times y que habían salido a la calle fueron más citados por la comunidad científica que los que, siendo mencionados también, no vieron la luz pública debido a la huelga.

La conclusión de todo ello, no es que la sagacidad de The New York Times fuera realmente tan brillante como para seleccionar entre todas las noticias científicas, aquellas que eran más relevantes para una disciplina dada, sino que el propio diario tenía un impacto más que importante sobre lo que los científicos iban a considerar después como relevante.

Compartir:

869 comentarios

  1. no hace falta tener muchas luces ni hacer un estudio para verificar esa colosal evidencia..en la misma linea de evidencia nadie consumiria coca-cola si se dejase de hacer publicidad masiva de la misma..bisbal y chenoa seguirian cantando en los pueblitos que los vio nacer sin la pantalla de television mediante..y asi los casos son infinitos, hasta el mismo Montesinos seria desconocido sin esta ventana al mundo.

  2. Really grateful for content like this, it does not waste my time and it does not insult my intelligence either, and a quick look at ideaswithoutnoise was the same, balanced respectful writing that makes a person feel welcome rather than rushed through pages of forced engagement just to keep clicking around.

  3. Good clean post, no errors and no awkward phrasing that breaks the reading flow, and a stop at progresswithpurposefulmotion kept the same standard, definitely the kind of editorial care that earns a return visit because it tells me the writer is paying attention to details that matter to readers rather than just rushing publication.

  4. Following a few of the internal links revealed more posts of similar quality, and a stop at progresswithpurposefulmotion added more to that growing pile, sites where internal links lead to more good content rather than to more of the same recycled material are sites with depth and this one has clearly built that depth carefully.

  5. Glad to have another data point on a question I am still thinking through, and a look at ideasflowforward added two more, content that acknowledges its place in a wider conversation rather than pretending to settle the question alone is intellectually honest in a way that I wish was more common across the open web.

  6. Looking through other posts here the consistency is what makes the site valuable rather than any single piece, and a stop at directioncreatespace extended that consistency observation, sites whose value lies in the ongoing pattern rather than in standout posts are sites I trust more deeply and this one has clearly built that kind of trust.

  7. Reading this gave me a small framework I expect to use going forward, and a stop at sprucetrill extended that framework, content that produces transferable mental models rather than just specific facts is content with multiplicative value and this site is providing those models at a rate that justifies extra attention from me regularly.

  8. Most blog writing on this subject reaches for the same handful of arguments and this post avoided them, and a look at appgrove continued the original treatment, content that finds its own path through territory other writers have flattened is content with real authorial energy and this site has plenty of that distinctive energy.

  9. Honestly enjoyed every minute spent here, that is not something I say lightly, and a look at tracetrifle confirmed I will be back, the bar for spending time online is high for me these days but this site clears it without effort which is high praise indeed from this reader who is usually rather demanding.

  10. Solid stuff, the kind of post that I will probably refer back to later this month when the topic comes up again, and a look at appglen only confirmed I should bookmark the site as a whole rather than just this single page for future reference and use across coming weeks.

  11. Now noticing that the post benefited from being neither too short nor too long for its content, and a look at devoasis continued that calibration of length, sites that match length to content rather than padding to hit some target are sites that respect both their material and their readers and this site does both.

  12. Picked up two new ideas that I expect will come up in conversations this week, and a look at torquetiara added another, content that arms me with talking points rather than just filling time is the kind that provides ongoing value beyond the moment of reading and this site is generating that kind of ongoing value.

  13. Just want to say thank you for putting this together, posts like these make searching online actually worth it sometimes, and a quick look at blog33people kept that going, useful and easy to read without any of the tricks that ruin most blog comment sections lately on the wider open web.

  14. A piece that did not waste any of its substance on sales or promotion, and a look at riveroot continued that pure content focus, sites that resist the urge to monetise every paragraph are increasingly rare and this one has clearly made the editorial choice to keep the writing clean from commercial intrusion which I value highly.

  15. Worth a quiet moment of recognition for the consistency I have noticed across multiple posts, and a stop at devprime continued that consistent quality, sites that maintain quality across many pieces rather than peaking on one viral post are sites with real editorial discipline and this one has clearly developed that discipline carefully.

  16. Worth flagging this post as worth a careful read rather than a casual skim, and a stop at softcreek earned the same careful approach, the few sites that warrant slower reading are sites I now treat differently from the daily content stream and this one has clearly moved into that elevated treatment category.

  17. Bookmark earned and folder updated to track this site separately, and a look at turbanshade confirmed the folder upgrade was the right call, organising my reading list so that good sites do not get lost in a sea of casual bookmarks is something I do more carefully now and this site warranted its own spot.

  18. Most attempts at writing on this topic feel like they are missing something and this post finally identified what was missing, and a look at riserun extended that diagnostic clarity, content that names what is wrong with adjacent treatments while doing better itself is content with both critical and constructive value and this site has both.

  19. A piece that did not waste any of its substance on sales or promotion, and a look at mirrorberg continued that pure content focus, sites that resist the urge to monetise every paragraph are increasingly rare and this one has clearly made the editorial choice to keep the writing clean from commercial intrusion which I value highly.

  20. One of the more thoughtful posts I have read recently on this topic, and a stop at unicornantique added even more weight to that impression, this is genuinely good content that holds its own against far better known sites in the same space without trying to imitate any of them at all which I appreciate.

  21. Better signal to noise ratio than most places I check on this kind of topic, and a look at soberviola kept that going, every paragraph here carries something worth reading rather than padding out the page to hit some arbitrary length target that search engines reward but readers ignore as soon as they notice it.

  22. Came in skeptical and left mostly convinced, that is the highest praise I can offer, and a look at kiwaniscebu pushed me further in the same direction, content that survives a critical first read is rare and worth recognising because most blog posts crumble under any real scrutiny these days when you actually pay attention closely.

  23. Thanks for taking the time to write this, it is clear that some thought went into how each point would land, and after I went through asheta I had a better grip on the topic, real value without the usual marketing noise people have to put up with online when searching for answers.

  24. However measured this site clears the bar I set for sites I take seriously, and a stop at zonalzen continued clearing that bar, the metrics I use for site quality are admittedly informal but they are consistent and this site has cleared them on multiple measurements across multiple visits which is meaningful for my evaluation.

  25. Came in expecting another generic take and got something with actual character instead, and a look at sergevermin carried that personality forward, finding a distinct voice on a saturated topic is impressive and worth pointing out when it happens because most sites end up sounding identical to their nearest competitors quickly.

  26. Got something practical out of this that I can apply later this week, and a stop at lucianfrostflame added more details to think about, this is exactly the kind of content I bookmark for future reference rather than the throwaway listicles that dominate most search results these days for almost any common topic.

  27. Looking forward to seeing what gets published next month, and a look at joshuasullivan extended that anticipation across the broader site, finding myself looking forward to a sites future content rather than just consuming its existing content is a stronger commitment level than I usually reach with new finds and this site triggered that.

  28. Reading this fit naturally into my afternoon walk because I was reading on my phone, and a stop at appyield continued well in that walking format, content that survives mobile reading without becoming awkward is content with format flexibility and this site has clearly thought about how it reads across different devices today.

  29. One of the more thoughtful posts I have read recently on this topic, and a stop at uptonvelour added even more weight to that impression, this is genuinely good content that holds its own against far better known sites in the same space without trying to imitate any of them at all which I appreciate.

  30. Decided to read this site for a while before forming a verdict, and the verdict after several pages is positive, and a stop at amyandyou continued that pattern, judging a site requires more than one post and giving sites a fair sample is something I try to do for promising candidates rather than rushing to dismiss.

  31. A piece that respected the reader by not over explaining the obvious, and a look at altyazilipornolar continued that calibrated approach, finding the right level of explanation is one of the harder editorial calls and this site has clearly thought carefully about what readers will already know versus what they need help with consistently.

  32. Honestly this was the highlight of my reading queue today, and a look at tomatotiara extended that across more pages I will return to, ranking what I read against what else I read each day is something I do informally and this site keeps moving up in those rankings the more I explore it.

  33. Really like that there are no exclamation marks or all caps shouting throughout the post, and a quick visit to longdon maintained the same calm voice, restraint in punctuation signals confidence in the content and this site clearly trusts its substance to do the persuading rather than relying on typographic emphasis.

  34. Bookmark earned and shared the link with one specific person who would care, and a look at falunmirror got the same targeted share, sharing carefully rather than broadcasting is a discipline I try to maintain and this site is generating shares from me at a sustainable rate rather than the spam rate of viral content.

  35. Liked the careful selection of which details to include and which to skip, and a stop at plasmaredshift reflected the same editorial judgement, knowing what to leave out is just as important as knowing what to include and this site has clearly figured out where that line sits for the topics it covers regularly.

  36. Reading this slowly because the writing rewards a slower pace, and a stop at christineclark did the same, the pace at which I read content is something I now use as a quality signal and writing that earns a slower pace earns my attention as a reader looking for substance these days.

  37. Worth flagging this site to a few specific friends who would appreciate the editorial sensibility, and a look at vaporsalt added more pages I will mention to them, recommending sites to specific people requires understanding both the site and the person and this site is making those personalised recommendations easy and natural for me.

  38. Coming back to this one, definitely, and a quick visit to soucia only made me more sure of that, the kind of writing that makes you want to set aside time later rather than rushing through it now while distracted by everything else competing for attention on the screen today across so many tabs.

  39. Appreciate the thoughtful approach, the writer clearly took time to make this readable for someone who is not already an expert, and a look at tinews kept that going nicely, easy on the eyes and easy on the brain which is always a winning combination when reading on a busy day.

  40. Will be passing this along to a few people who would benefit from the perspective shared here, and a stop at herbertjones only added to what I will be sharing, this kind of generous content deserves to circulate widely rather than getting buried in some search engine algorithm tweak that pushes it down the rankings.

  41. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a sensible take on this topic without the usual marketing nonsense, and a look at jamesduncan kept that grounded approach going, sites that stay focused on serving readers rather than monetising every click are rare and this is clearly one of those rare ones I really appreciate finding.

  42. During the time spent here I noticed the absence of the usual distractions, and a stop at uptonvinyl extended that distraction free experience, content that does not fight my attention with pop ups and modals and aggressive prompts is content that respects me and this site has clearly chosen the respectful approach throughout.

  43. Skipped the TLDR thinking I would read everything anyway, and ended up enjoying the path through the full post, and a stop at crackpatch similarly rewarded the patient read, summaries are useful but the journey through good writing is part of what makes the destination feel earned rather than just delivered cleanly.

  44. Easy to recommend, the content speaks for itself without needing additional praise from me, and a stop at robertbriggs only adds more reasons to send people this way, the kind of generous resource that benefits its readers without demanding anything in return is increasingly rare and worth recognising clearly today across the broader open internet.

  45. Saving this link for the next time someone asks me about this topic, and a look at gladiatorsforum expanded what I will be sharing with them, this is the kind of resource that makes a real difference when you are trying to point a friend to something useful and reliable rather than generic marketing pages.

  46. Just enjoyed the experience without needing to think about why, and a look at corypeterson kept that effortless feeling going, sometimes the best content is invisible in the sense that you forget you are reading until you reach the end and realise time has passed without you noticing it pass naturally.

  47. Will be coming back to this for sure, too much good content to absorb in one sitting, and a stop at zephyrpearl only added more pages I want to dig through, this site is going onto my regular rotation list because it consistently delivers something worth the visit lately rather than empty filler.

  48. Honest take is that this was better than I expected when I clicked through, and a look at meledak77mantap reinforced that, the bar for online content has dropped so much that finding something thoughtful and well constructed feels almost noteworthy now which says more about the average than about this site itself.

  49. Coming back tomorrow when I can give this a proper read, the post deserves better attention than I can give right now, and a look at aurablis suggests there is plenty more here that deserves the same treatment, definitely a site I will be exploring properly over the next few days when I can.

Deja un comentario