Otra vez los índices de impacto y su significado

En este blog he insistido en el hecho de que ya no se evalúa la ciencia por lo que se publica, si no dónde se publica y nos limitamos a «sumar» o «promediar» índices de impacto (Impact Factor, IF) de las revistas en las que se publica en vez de valorar el artículo individualmente. También he insistido en que los IFs se usan «alegremente», muchas veces sin conocer su significado real.

Hoy traigo a esta página un ejemplo espectacular que nos tiene que hacer reflexionar sobre el valor que puede tener el IF de las publicaciones científicas.

Se acaba de publicar el IF correspondiente a los artículos publicados en 2008. Y hay un cambio espectacular. La revista Acta Crystallographica Section A (Foundations of Crystallography) ha aumentado su IF en casi 25 veces, pasado de un digno 2’05  a un espectacular 49’93. ¿Por qué ha sido esto? ¿Ha aumentado la calidad de los artículos publicado? ¿Ha aumentado la exigencia del editor?

NO. La razón es que se ha publicado un artículo excelente y que toda la comunidad cristalográfica llevaba años esperando: A short history of SHELX por George M. Sheldrick, el «inventor» del programa SHELX, que es la herramienta computacional fundamental para refinar estructuras cristalográficas. Este artículo ha sido citado 6653 veces (a 25 de junio de 2010), con casi 6000 citas entre 2008 y 2009.

El segundo artículo más citado de Acta Crystallographica Section A ha sido citado 31 veces, el 10º más citado, 11 veces; hay 17 artículos que han sido citado 2 o una vez y hay 19 artículos que no han sido citados (de un total de 72 artículos publicados en 2008).

Como ya he pedido en este blog, leamos las publicaciones y veamos cuanto se ha citado cada artículo individualmente; especialmente, cuando tengamo que evaluar CVs para plazas, contratos, etc. Si seguimos teniendo en cuenta solo el índice de impacto de las revista, cometeremos injusticias. Si no cambiamos el sistema, solo me queda felicitar a los que hayan publicado en 2008 en Acta Crystallographica Section A, pues tendrán artículos con un IF de casi 50, aunque nunca haya sido citado.

P. D.: Por cierto, os habréis fijado que, sin cambiar prácticamente, la revista ha pasado de ser casi despreciada por los que solo publican por índice de impacto a ser una revista «excelente».

Bernardo Herradón

IQOG-CSIC

herradon@iqog.csic.es

Compartir:

742 comentarios

  1. Such writing is increasingly rare and worth supporting through attention, and a stop at strategicconnectionbond extended that supportive attention across more pages, the conscious choice to spend time on sites that produce careful work rather than convenient consumption is itself a small form of patronage and this site is receiving that conscious patronage from me.

  2. I came here looking for a quick answer and ended up reading the whole post because it was actually interesting, and after progressblueprint I had a much fuller picture, no stress and no confusion just a clear walk through the topic that made everything fall into place without much effort.

  3. Skipped a meeting reminder to finish the post, and a stop at signalactivatesgrowth held me past another reminder, when content beats meetings the writer is doing something extraordinary because meetings have institutional support behind them and yet good writing can still occasionally win that competition for attention which I find heartening today.

  4. Really appreciate that the writer did not overstate the importance of the topic to make the post feel weightier, and a quick visit to signalfeedsmomentum maintained the same modest framing, content that is honest about its own scope rather than inflating itself is the kind I trust and return to repeatedly over time.

  5. My usual response to new bookmarks is to forget them but this one I have already returned to twice, and a look at directionalintelligence pulled me back a third time, the actual return rate to bookmarked sites is the real measure of value and this one is clearing that measure at a notable rate already.

  6. Closed it feeling slightly more competent in the topic than I started, and a stop at actionpathfinder reinforced that competence boost, real learning is rare in casual online reading but it does happen sometimes and this site managed to make it happen for me today which is genuinely worth pausing to acknowledge.

  7. Easy to recommend without reservations, the site delivers on every promise it implicitly makes, and a look at longtermtrustnetwork kept that same standard going, the kind of consistency that earns trust over time rather than chasing it through aggressive marketing is what I see here and it is appreciated greatly by this particular reader today.

  8. A piece that read smoothly because the writer understood how readers actually move through prose, and a look at growthflowswithclarity maintained the same reader awareness, writers who think about the reading experience as much as the writing experience produce better work and this site has clearly made that shift in editorial approach.

  9. Glad I clicked through from where I did because this turned out to be worth the time spent, and after claritybuilderhub I had a fuller picture, the kind of content that earns its visitors through delivering value rather than chasing them through aggressive advertising or constant pop ups appearing everywhere on the screen lately.

  10. Now considering whether the post would translate well into a different form, and a look at directionchannelsprogress suggested similar versatility, content that could move into other media without losing its substance is content that has been built around ideas rather than around format and this site reads as idea first throughout posts.

  11. Now recognising the editorial wisdom of letting some questions remain open at the end, and a look at directionalprocess continued that intellectual honesty, content that does not force closure on contested questions is content that respects the limits of knowledge and this site has clearly developed the maturity to know when to leave space.

  12. Excellent execution from start to finish, the post never loses its rhythm and the points stay sharp, and a quick stop at focusbuildsresults kept the same level going, consistency like this across a site is the marker of a serious operation rather than a casual side project running on autopilot somewhere else.

  13. Considered against the flood of similar content this one stands apart in important ways, and a stop at actionmomentum extended that distinctive feel, sites that find their own corner of a crowded topic and stay there are sites worth following and this one has clearly carved out its own space and committed to defending it carefully.

  14. Speaking from the perspective of a fairly demanding reader the writing here clears the bar consistently, and a look at growthmoveswithstructure continued clearing that bar, the calibration of demanding reader is something I apply to all sources and this site has been one of the few that handles the demanding reading well across pieces sampled.

  15. Good post, the kind that respects the reader by getting to the point quickly without skipping the details that matter, and a short look at actionconstructor confirmed that approach is consistent across the site which is rare to find online these days, definitely a place I will return to soon.

  16. Bookmark added with a small mental note that this is a site to keep, and a look at unitytrustbond reinforced the keep status, the verb keep rather than visit captures something about how I think about this kind of site and it is a higher tier of relationship than I have with most places online today.

  17. Now feeling slightly more optimistic about the state of independent writing online, and a stop at focusguidesmovement extended that quiet optimism, sites like this one are the reason I have not given up on the open web entirely and finding them occasionally renews the case for paying attention to non algorithmic content sources today.

  18. Halfway through I knew I would finish the post, and a stop at bondedstability also held me through to the end, content that signals its quality early and then sustains it is content with real internal consistency and this site has clearly figured out how to maintain quality from opening sentence through to closing thought.

  19. Liked the natural conversational tone throughout, never stiff and never overly casual either, and a stop at actioncreatesforwardpath kept that comfortable middle ground going, finding a tone that respects the reader without becoming distant or overly familiar is harder than it sounds and this site nails that balance consistently across many different pieces.

  20. Reading the writers other posts after this one suggests the quality is consistent rather than peak, and a stop at collaborativepowergroup confirmed the consistent quality reading, sites that hold the same level across many pieces rather than peaking on a few are sites with sustainable editorial discipline and this one has clearly developed that.

  21. Now appreciating that the post did not require me to agree with the writer to find it valuable, and a look at momentumplanning maintained the same useful regardless of agreement quality, content that informs even when it does not convince is content with broader utility and this site reads as useful even when I disagree.

  22. Worth observing that the post landed without needing a flashy headline to hook attention, and a stop at businessbondcircle did the same, content that earns engagement through substance rather than packaging is the kind I trust more deeply and this site has clearly chosen substance as the primary lever for reader engagement throughout.

  23. More original than the recycled takes I keep finding on the topic elsewhere, and a quick look at claritysystems confirmed it, the kind of site that has its own voice rather than echoing whatever is trending which makes it stand out as a refreshing change from the usual rotation of generic content I see daily.

  24. Approaching this site through a casual link click and being surprised by what I found, and a look at strongalliancelink extended the surprise, the rare experience of stumbling into excellent independent content rather than predictable mediocrity is one of the actual remaining pleasures of casual web browsing and this site provided it cleanly.

  25. Top quality material, deserves more attention than it probably gets, and a look at actionmovesstrategy reflected the same effort across the site, a hidden gem in the modern web where most attention goes to whoever shouts loudest rather than whoever actually delivers the best content for their readers without much marketing fanfare.

  26. Picked this up between two other things I was doing and got drawn in completely, and after growtharchitect my original tasks were completely forgotten for a while, content that derails a workflow in a positive way by being more interesting than what you were already doing is rare and worth recognising clearly.

  27. Reading this gave me confidence to make a decision I had been putting off, and a stop at momentumactivation reinforced that confidence, content that translates into action in my own life rather than just informing it is content with the highest practical value and this site is generating that action level utility for me lately.

  28. Will be coming back to this for sure, too much good content to absorb in one sitting, and a stop at businessunitynetwork only added more pages I want to dig through, this site is going onto my regular rotation list because it consistently delivers something worth the visit lately rather than empty filler.

  29. Came away with some new perspectives I had not considered before, and after progressflowswithclarity those ideas felt more complete, the kind of content that stays with you a little while after reading rather than slipping out the moment you switch tabs and move on with your day to whatever comes next.

  30. Started smiling at one paragraph because the writing was just nice, and a look at actioncreatespathways produced a couple more such moments, prose that produces small spontaneous reactions in the reader is doing more than just transferring information and the writers here are clearly hitting that level fairly consistently throughout pieces.

  31. Adding this site to my regular reading list, the post earned that on its own, and a quick stop at forwardpathway sealed the decision, the kind of place worth checking back with from time to time because it consistently produces material that holds up against a critical reading too which I really value.

  32. Coming to this with low expectations and being pleasantly surprised by the substance, and a stop at claritymotionlab continued exceeding expectations, the recalibration of expectations upward across multiple positive readings is one of the actual rewards of careful browsing and this site is providing that recalibration at a steady rate apparently.

  33. Found a couple of useful angles in here I had not considered before reading carefully, and a quick stop at signalshapesprogress added more, this is one of those sites where the value compounds the more you read rather than peaking at one viral post and then offering nothing else of substance afterwards which is common.

  34. Probably going to mention this site in a write up I am working on later this month, and a stop at claritycreatesprogress provided more material for that potential mention, content worth referencing in my own published work rather than just personal reading is content with the highest endorsement level and this site has earned that endorsement.

  35. Well done, the kind of post that makes you slow down and actually read instead of skimming for keywords, and a look at truebondnetwork kept me reading carefully too, that is a sign of writing that has been crafted rather than churned out for an algorithm to see today and tomorrow.

  36. Appreciate the thoughtful approach, the writer clearly took time to make this readable for someone who is not already an expert, and a look at bondedcollective kept that going nicely, easy on the eyes and easy on the brain which is always a winning combination when reading on a busy day.

  37. Different in a good way from the cookie cutter content that fills most blogs covering this area, and a stop at signalcreatesdirectionalflow kept showing me why, original thoughtful writing exists if you know where to look and this site has earned a place on my short list of those rare exceptions worth defending.

  38. Closed the laptop after this and let the ideas settle for a few hours, and a stop at claritylane similarly rewarded reflective time, content that benefits from sitting with rather than racing past is the kind I want more of and the kind that this site appears to consistently produce week after week here.

  39. During a reading session that included several other sources this one stood out, and a look at ideaexecutionhub continued the standout quality, the side by side comparison of sources during research is a useful exercise and this site has been winning those comparisons for me consistently across multiple research sessions during the last week.

  40. Liked the balance between depth and brevity, never too shallow and never too long, and a stop at forwardpathconstructed kept the same balance going across the rest of the site, this is one of the harder skills in writing and the team here clearly has it figured out very well indeed across every page.

  41. Now setting this aside as a model of how to write thoughtfully on the topic, and a stop at growthlogic extended that model status, content that becomes a reference for how a kind of writing should be done is content with influence beyond its own readership and this site is reaching that level for me clearly today.

  42. Took the time to read the comments on this post too and they were also worth reading, and a stop at directionanchorsmotion suggested the community quality matches the content quality, when the conversation around a piece is as good as the piece itself you know you have found a real corner of the internet.

  43. If I had to summarise the editorial sensibility of this site in a few words it would be careful and human, and a look at trustedrelationshipnet extended that summary feeling, capturing the essence of a sites approach in brief is hard but this site has a clear enough identity that the summary comes naturally enough.

  44. Honestly slowed down to read this carefully which is not my default, and a look at progressengineered kept me in that careful reading mode, the kind of writing that demands attention by being worth attention is rare in a media environment full of content engineered to be skimmed not read with any real focus today.

  45. A genuine pleasure to find a site that publishes at a sustainable cadence rather than chasing the daily content treadmill, and a look at visionarybondcircle confirmed the careful publication rhythm, sites that prioritise quality over frequency are rare and this one has clearly chosen the slower pace which I appreciate as a reader.

  46. A piece that took its time without dragging, and a look at ideaconverter kept the same patient pace, the difference between unhurried and slow is a fine editorial distinction and this site has clearly found the unhurried side without slipping into the slow side which would have lost me as a reader quickly otherwise.

  47. Looking through the archives suggests this site has been doing this for a while at this level, and a look at futuregrowthalliance confirmed the long term consistency, sites that have maintained quality across years rather than just a recent stretch are sites with serious editorial discipline and this one has clearly been at it for a while.

  48. Quiet confidence runs through the whole post, no need to shout to make the points stick, and a stop at ideasgainalignment carried that same restrained voice forward, content that respects the reader by trusting its own substance rather than dressing it up in theatrical language is what I look for online and rarely actually find these days.

  49. Picked this for my morning read because the topic seemed worth the time, and a look at strategyactivation confirmed the choice was right, my morning reading slot is precious and giving it to this site felt like a good investment rather than a waste which is a higher endorsement than I usually offer for content.

  50. Reading this in a quiet hour and finding it suited the quiet, and a stop at focuscreatesdirection extended the quiet reading mood, content that matches its own optimal reading conditions rather than fighting them is content that has been thoughtfully calibrated and this site reads as having a particular reading mood in mind throughout.

Deja un comentario