![]()
Otra vez los índices de impacto y su significado
En este blog he insistido en el hecho de que ya no se evalúa la ciencia por lo que se publica, si no dónde se publica y nos limitamos a «sumar» o «promediar» índices de impacto (Impact Factor, IF) de las revistas en las que se publica en vez de valorar el artículo individualmente. También he insistido en que los IFs se usan «alegremente», muchas veces sin conocer su significado real.
Hoy traigo a esta página un ejemplo espectacular que nos tiene que hacer reflexionar sobre el valor que puede tener el IF de las publicaciones científicas.
Se acaba de publicar el IF correspondiente a los artículos publicados en 2008. Y hay un cambio espectacular. La revista Acta Crystallographica Section A (Foundations of Crystallography) ha aumentado su IF en casi 25 veces, pasado de un digno 2’05 a un espectacular 49’93. ¿Por qué ha sido esto? ¿Ha aumentado la calidad de los artículos publicado? ¿Ha aumentado la exigencia del editor?
NO. La razón es que se ha publicado un artículo excelente y que toda la comunidad cristalográfica llevaba años esperando: A short history of SHELX por George M. Sheldrick, el «inventor» del programa SHELX, que es la herramienta computacional fundamental para refinar estructuras cristalográficas. Este artículo ha sido citado 6653 veces (a 25 de junio de 2010), con casi 6000 citas entre 2008 y 2009.
El segundo artículo más citado de Acta Crystallographica Section A ha sido citado 31 veces, el 10º más citado, 11 veces; hay 17 artículos que han sido citado 2 o una vez y hay 19 artículos que no han sido citados (de un total de 72 artículos publicados en 2008).
Como ya he pedido en este blog, leamos las publicaciones y veamos cuanto se ha citado cada artículo individualmente; especialmente, cuando tengamo que evaluar CVs para plazas, contratos, etc. Si seguimos teniendo en cuenta solo el índice de impacto de las revista, cometeremos injusticias. Si no cambiamos el sistema, solo me queda felicitar a los que hayan publicado en 2008 en Acta Crystallographica Section A, pues tendrán artículos con un IF de casi 50, aunque nunca haya sido citado.
P. D.: Por cierto, os habréis fijado que, sin cambiar prácticamente, la revista ha pasado de ser casi despreciada por los que solo publican por índice de impacto a ser una revista «excelente».
Bernardo Herradón
IQOG-CSIC
Reading this slowly to absorb the structure, and the structure is doing real work alongside the words, and a look at gladiatorsforum maintained the same architectural quality, when sentence shapes and paragraph rhythms reinforce the meaning rather than just transporting words you know you are reading skilled work today.
Now thinking about whether the writer might publish a longer form work I would buy, and a look at corypeterson suggested the same depth would translate, content that makes me want to pay for related work in other formats is content that has earned commercial trust as well as attention trust and this site has both clearly.
Recommended without hesitation if you care about careful coverage of this topic, and a stop at meledak77mantap reinforced the recommendation, the bar I set for unhesitating recommendations is fairly high and this site has cleared it through the cumulative weight of multiple consistently good pieces rather than through any single standout post which is meaningful.
Skipped the comments to avoid spoilers and came back later to find them genuinely worth reading, and a stop at twainskipper extended that surprised respect, when the discussion below a post matches the quality of the post itself you have found something special and this site appears to attract that kind of audience.
A slim post with substantial content per word, and a look at magisteriuma maintained the same density, the content per word ratio is something I track informally and this site scores high on that ratio compared to most sources I read regularly which is a quiet indicator of careful editorial work behind the scenes.
A piece that did not require external context to follow, and a look at aurablis maintained the same self contained quality, content that stands alone without forcing readers to chase prerequisites is more accessible and this site has clearly thought about how each piece can serve a fresh visitor rather than only existing members.
Really appreciate the absence of stock photos that have nothing to do with the content, and a quick visit to mage77-rtp maintained the same restraint, visual filler is a tell that the writing cannot stand on its own and the lack of it here suggests the team has confidence in their content quality alone.
Worth saying that the post fit naturally into a rhythm of careful reading, and a stop at joshuablackwellmd extended the same rhythm, content that pairs well with how I actually read rather than demanding a different mode is content well calibrated to its likely audience and this site has clearly thought about that consistently.
Skipped to a specific section because I knew that was the question I had, and the answer was clean, and a stop at mariahill similarly delivered targeted answers without burying them, content engineered for readers who arrive with specific needs rather than open ended browsing is increasingly valuable in a search heavy reading environment.
Going to come back when I have more time to read carefully, the post deserves more than a quick scan, and a stop at voxshop reinforced that, this is the kind of site that rewards a slower read which is hard to find in this fast paced corner of the internet but really worthwhile.
During my morning reading slot this fit perfectly into the routine, and a look at a-nz49 extended that perfect fit into the rest of the routine, content that matches the rhythm of how I actually read rather than demanding accommodation from my schedule is content well calibrated to its likely audience and this site has it.
Honestly the simplicity of the explanation made the topic click for me in a way other writeups had not, and a look at sandaltrust continued that clarity into related areas, when a writer gets the level of explanation right the reader does the heavy lifting themselves and the post just enables it.
Genuinely useful read, the points are practical and easy to apply right away, and a quick look at haircover confirmed that this site is consistent in that approach, looking forward to digging through the rest of it when I get the chance to sit down properly later in the week or this weekend.
Picked this up while looking for something else and ended up reading every paragraph because it was actually informative, and after debrabowen I was sure I would come back, that does not happen often when most sites bury the useful parts under endless ads and pop ups today and across most categories online.
Thanks for a post that does not try to be funny when it is not the moment for it, and a stop at crackfine maintained the same appropriate seriousness, knowing when humour helps and when it just signals desperation for engagement is a sign of editorial maturity that many blogs have not developed yet.
Just want to say thank you for putting this together, posts like these make searching online actually worth it sometimes, and a quick look at chousea kept that going, useful and easy to read without any of the tricks that ruin most blog comment sections lately on the wider open web.
My usual pattern is to skim and bounce but this site has reset that pattern temporarily, and a stop at zonalzone maintained the slower reading mode, content that changes how I read is content with structural influence and this site has clearly nudged my reading behaviour toward something better at least for the duration of these visits.
Looking through other posts here the consistency is what makes the site valuable rather than any single piece, and a stop at pomswap extended that consistency observation, sites whose value lies in the ongoing pattern rather than in standout posts are sites I trust more deeply and this one has clearly built that kind of trust.
Took a few notes from this post, the points are easy to remember without needing to come back and check, and a look at squaresloop added a couple more, the kind of place that sticks in the memory long after the browser tab has been closed for the day which says a lot really.
Now understanding why someone recommended this site to me a while back, and a stop at devthrive explained the recommendation, sometimes recommendations make sense only after experience and this site has finally clicked into place as the kind of resource I now understand was being recommended for sound editorial reasons by my friend.
The structure of the post made it easy to follow without losing track of where I was, and a look at setterstudio kept the same logical flow going, this site clearly understands that organisation is half the battle in keeping readers engaged from the first line to the last across any kind of post.
Taking the time to read carefully here has been worthwhile for the past hour, and a look at juliabarker extended the worthwhile reading, the calculation of return on reading time spent is something I do informally and this site has been producing positive returns across multiple sessions during the last week of regular visits and reads.
A genuine compliment to the writer for keeping the post focused on what mattered, and a look at alphaapp continued that disciplined focus, focus is a editorial choice that compounds across many small decisions and this site has clearly made those small decisions consistently across what I have read so far this week here.
Started forming counter examples to test the claims and the post handled most of them implicitly, and a look at dylbray continued that anticipatory style, writers who think two steps ahead of the critical reader save themselves from a lot of follow up work and this writer has clearly internalised that habit consistently.
Now organising my browser bookmarks to give this site easier access, and a look at qinlji earned the same organisational priority, the small acts of digital housekeeping I do for sites I expect to use often are themselves a measure of trust and this site has triggered the trust based housekeeping behaviour from me clearly.
Took something from this I did not expect to find, and a stop at convertersa added another unexpected useful piece, content that exceeds expectations rather than just meeting them is the kind that builds enthusiasm and earns repeat visits without any explicit ask from the writer or platform behind the work being read.
Genuine reaction is that I will probably think about this on and off for a few days, and a look at tonybarnes added fuel to that, the best content lingers in your head after you close the tab rather than evaporating immediately and this site clearly knows how to write that kind of memorable content.
Thanks for not padding this with the usual filler intros and outros that every other blog seems to require, and a quick visit to dylcane continued that lean approach across more posts, content stripped of waste is content that respects you and I will always come back to that kind of approach.
Worth flagging this site to a few specific friends who would appreciate the editorial sensibility, and a look at zonalzeny added more pages I will mention to them, recommending sites to specific people requires understanding both the site and the person and this site is making those personalised recommendations easy and natural for me.
I really like how the writer keeps the tone friendly without sounding fake or overly polished, and after a stop at bedheada the same calm pace was there, no rushing to make a point and no padding either, just clean honest writing that I can respect and come back to later again.
My professional context would benefit from having this kind of resource available, and a look at tatersa extended the professional applicability, the rare site that contributes meaningfully to professional work rather than just personal interest is content with multiplied value and this one is providing that professional utility consistently across multiple pieces.
Came away with a slightly better mental model of the topic than I started with, and a stop at tottori-seibu-delivery-yellmart sharpened that further, content that improves the reader thinking apparatus rather than just dumping facts into it is the rare kind I genuinely value and seek out when I have time to read carefully.
Most of my reading time goes to a small number of trusted sources and this one is now joining that group, and a stop at blog44threes reinforced the group membership, the few sites that earn a place in my regular rotation are sites I expect ongoing returns from and this one has earned that elevated position consistently.
Decent post that improved my afternoon a small amount, and a look at blog44hits added a bit more to that, sometimes the small wins online add up over time and a useful site like this one is the kind of place that contributes consistently to those small wins for me lately across many different topics I follow.
A memorable post for me on a topic I had thought I was tired of, and a look at blog44choices suggested the same site can refresh other tired topics, sites that can revive my interest in subjects I had written off as exhausted are doing rare work and this one is clearly doing that for me today.
Worth pointing out that the writer made the topic feel more interesting than I had been expecting, and a look at emmywrite continued that elevation effect, content that improves the apparent quality of its subject through skilled treatment is doing something real and this site has clearly developed that kind of editorial alchemy throughout.
Looking at the surface design and the substance together this site has both right, and a look at oregoncityparks reinforced that integrated quality, sites where presentation and content reinforce each other rather than fighting are sites with full editorial coherence and this one has clearly invested in both layers in a balanced way.
Reading this post made me realise I had been settling for lower quality elsewhere, and a look at appgiant extended that recalibration, content that exposes how much I had been accepting in adjacent sources is content with calibrating effect on my standards and this site is performing that calibration function across topics for me reliably.
Solid information that lines up with what I have been hearing from other reliable sources, and after my visit to acapparelstores I was even more certain of that, this site checks out which is something I value highly when so many places online play loose with the facts to chase a quick click.
Pass this along to colleagues if the topic comes up, the framing here is sensible, and a stop at horizonhub adds more useful angles to share, the kind of content that improves conversations rather than just feeding them is what makes a resource genuinely valuable in professional contexts going forward over time and across project boundaries too.
Bookmarking this for later, the kind of resource I want to keep nearby, and a quick look at blog66glass confirmed the rest of the site is worth the same treatment, definitely going into my reference folder for the next time the topic comes up at work or in conversation with someone who asks.
Worth a slow read rather than the fast scan I usually default to, and a look at easedash earned the same slower pace from me, content that resets my reading speed downward is content with substance worth absorbing and this site has produced that effect on me multiple times now over the last week here.
Top quality material, deserves more attention than it probably gets, and a look at shularrfashion reflected the same effort across the site, a hidden gem in the modern web where most attention goes to whoever shouts loudest rather than whoever actually delivers the best content for their readers without much marketing fanfare.
Reading this prompted me to send the link to two different people for two different reasons, and a stop at devdepot provided ammunition for a third share, content that suits multiple audiences without being generic enough to be useless to any of them is genuinely valuable and this site has that multi audience quality clearly.
Thanks for the practical examples scattered through the post rather than abstract theory only, and a look at carnaubaa continued that grounded style, abstract points are easier to remember when paired with concrete situations and the writers here clearly understand how readers actually retain information from blog content reading sessions.
Really appreciate the confidence to make a clear point rather than hedging everything, and a quick visit to ridgeroute maintained the same direct stance, writing that takes positions rather than equivocating is more useful even when the positions are debatable because at least the reader has something to react to clearly.
Thanks for keeping things clear and to the point, that is honestly hard to find online these days, and after reading through usbestsports the message stayed consistent which makes me trust the information being shared more than I usually do on similar pages that cover this same kind of topic.
Over the course of reading several posts here a pattern of quality has emerged, and a stop at trendystyleco confirmed the pattern, the difference between sites that hit quality occasionally and sites that hit it consistently is huge and this site has clearly demonstrated the consistent kind through what I have read this morning.
Really appreciate the confidence to make a clear point rather than hedging everything, and a quick visit to devpinnacle maintained the same direct stance, writing that takes positions rather than equivocating is more useful even when the positions are debatable because at least the reader has something to react to clearly.
Now appreciating that the post left me with enough to say in a follow up conversation, and a look at robinhudson added more material for those follow ups, content that prepares me for related conversations rather than just informing me alone is content with social utility and this site provides that social armament reliably for me.