![]()
Otra vez los índices de impacto y su significado
En este blog he insistido en el hecho de que ya no se evalúa la ciencia por lo que se publica, si no dónde se publica y nos limitamos a «sumar» o «promediar» índices de impacto (Impact Factor, IF) de las revistas en las que se publica en vez de valorar el artículo individualmente. También he insistido en que los IFs se usan «alegremente», muchas veces sin conocer su significado real.
Hoy traigo a esta página un ejemplo espectacular que nos tiene que hacer reflexionar sobre el valor que puede tener el IF de las publicaciones científicas.
Se acaba de publicar el IF correspondiente a los artículos publicados en 2008. Y hay un cambio espectacular. La revista Acta Crystallographica Section A (Foundations of Crystallography) ha aumentado su IF en casi 25 veces, pasado de un digno 2’05 a un espectacular 49’93. ¿Por qué ha sido esto? ¿Ha aumentado la calidad de los artículos publicado? ¿Ha aumentado la exigencia del editor?
NO. La razón es que se ha publicado un artículo excelente y que toda la comunidad cristalográfica llevaba años esperando: A short history of SHELX por George M. Sheldrick, el «inventor» del programa SHELX, que es la herramienta computacional fundamental para refinar estructuras cristalográficas. Este artículo ha sido citado 6653 veces (a 25 de junio de 2010), con casi 6000 citas entre 2008 y 2009.
El segundo artículo más citado de Acta Crystallographica Section A ha sido citado 31 veces, el 10º más citado, 11 veces; hay 17 artículos que han sido citado 2 o una vez y hay 19 artículos que no han sido citados (de un total de 72 artículos publicados en 2008).
Como ya he pedido en este blog, leamos las publicaciones y veamos cuanto se ha citado cada artículo individualmente; especialmente, cuando tengamo que evaluar CVs para plazas, contratos, etc. Si seguimos teniendo en cuenta solo el índice de impacto de las revista, cometeremos injusticias. Si no cambiamos el sistema, solo me queda felicitar a los que hayan publicado en 2008 en Acta Crystallographica Section A, pues tendrán artículos con un IF de casi 50, aunque nunca haya sido citado.
P. D.: Por cierto, os habréis fijado que, sin cambiar prácticamente, la revista ha pasado de ser casi despreciada por los que solo publican por índice de impacto a ser una revista «excelente».
Bernardo Herradón
IQOG-CSIC
Honestly enjoyed reading this more than I expected to when I first clicked through, and a stop at robertbernard kept that pleasant surprise going, sometimes you stumble onto a site that just clicks with how you like to read and this is one of those for me right now today which is great.
Probably this is one of the better quiet successes on the open web at the moment, and a look at sagestack reinforced that quiet success quality, sites that are doing well without making a noise about doing well are the sites I most respect and this one has clearly chosen the quiet success path consistently throughout.
Honestly thank you to whoever wrote this because it scratched an itch I had not quite been able to articulate, and a stop at grovegrid kept that satisfying feeling going, the kind of writing that meets unspoken needs is special and this site clearly has writers who understand their readers more than most do today.
Worth bookmarking and sharing with anyone interested in the topic, that is my honest take, and a stop at voltajapan reinforces that, the kind of generous resource that makes the open web feel worth defending against the constant pressure to retreat into walled gardens and curated feeds today everywhere I look across all my devices.
Felt a small spark of recognition when the post named something I had been struggling to articulate, and a look at a-nz33 produced more such moments, the rare service of giving readers language for fuzzy intuitions is one of the higher values that good writing can provide and this site offered several today instances.
Now leaving a small mental note to recommend this when the topic comes up in conversation, and a look at voidverse extended that recommend ready feeling, content that arms me with shareable references for likely future conversations is content with social value and this site is providing that conversational ammunition consistently for me lately.
Thanks for putting in the work to make this approachable, plenty of sites cover the same ground but most do it badly, and a quick visit to asymmetriesa confirmed this one stands apart, simple language and useful examples without anyone trying to sell me anything along the way which I really appreciated.
The lack of unnecessary jargon made the post accessible without sacrificing accuracy, and a look at appvineyard continued in the same accessible style, technical topics often hide behind specialised vocabulary but here the writer trusts the reader to keep up with plain language and that trust pays off nicely throughout the entire post.
Most posts I read end up forgotten within a day but this one is sticking, and a look at balinesea extended that lingering effect, content that survives the immediate moment of reading rather than evaporating is content with genuine retention quality and this site has been producing memorable pieces at a rate notable across my reading.
Reading this confirmed a hunch I had been carrying about the topic without having articulated it, and a stop at solidstack extended the confirmation, content that gives shape to fuzzy intuitions is doing the rare work of making private thoughts public and this site is providing that articulating service consistently for me lately.
A piece that did not waste any of its substance on sales or promotion, and a look at blog33reality continued that pure content focus, sites that resist the urge to monetise every paragraph are increasingly rare and this one has clearly made the editorial choice to keep the writing clean from commercial intrusion which I value highly.
Once I had read three posts the editorial pattern was clear, and a look at scrapya confirmed the pattern from a fourth angle, sites where the underlying approach reveals itself through accumulated reading rather than being announced are sites with real depth and this one has that quality clearly visible across multiple pieces consistently.
Worth every minute of the time spent reading, and a stop at validtrove extends that value across more pages, in a media environment where most content is engineered to waste attention this site stands out by treating reader time as something valuable rather than something to be exploited and stretched as far as possible.
Reading this post made me realise I had been settling for lower quality elsewhere, and a look at matrixmode extended that recalibration, content that exposes how much I had been accepting in adjacent sources is content with calibrating effect on my standards and this site is performing that calibration function across topics for me reliably.
Started reading without much expectation and ended on a high note, and a look at dawncore continued that arc, content that builds rather than peaks early is a sign of a writer who knows how to structure a piece for sustained reader engagement rather than relying on a strong hook to do all the work.
A slim post with substantial content per word, and a look at penvibes maintained the same density, the content per word ratio is something I track informally and this site scores high on that ratio compared to most sources I read regularly which is a quiet indicator of careful editorial work behind the scenes.
The way the post stayed on topic throughout without going on tangents was really refreshing, and a look at dataoasis kept that focused approach going, discipline like this in writing is rare and worth recognising because most writers cannot resist wandering off into related subjects that dilute their main point and confuse readers along the way.
Liked that the post landed without needing to manufacture controversy or take a contrarian stance for attention, and a stop at clementecenter continued that grounded approach, content that earns attention through quality rather than provocation is the kind that builds long term trust rather than burning it on quick wins.
Thanks for the clean writing, no broken sentences and no awkward translations like some other sites have, and a quick stop at blog33per kept that polish going nicely, it really does make a difference when a reader can move through a page without tripping on every line or going back to reread.
Reading this triggered a small change in how I think about the topic going forward, and a stop at teezambia reinforced that subtle shift, the rare content that actually moves my thinking rather than just confirming or filling it is the kind I most value and this site is providing that kind of impact today.
A genuine compliment to the writer for keeping the post focused on what mattered, and a look at zeeboutique continued that disciplined focus, focus is a editorial choice that compounds across many small decisions and this site has clearly made those small decisions consistently across what I have read so far this week here.
Started reading skeptically because the headline seemed overconfident, and the post earned the headline by the end, and a look at blog66full continued that pattern of earning its claims, sites that can back up their headlines without overpromising are rare and this one has clearly developed editorial calibration on that front consistently.
Felt no urge to argue with the conclusions even though I started the post slightly skeptical, and a look at bradleyhart maintained that pattern, writing that earns agreement through clarity of argument rather than rhetorical pressure is the kind I find most persuasive and the kind I want to read more of these days.
Beats most of the alternatives on the topic by a noticeable margin, and a look at mariesnyder did not change that at all, this is one of the better corners of the open internet for this kind of content and I am glad I clicked through rather than skipping past quickly like I usually do.
Reading this triggered a small reorganisation of my own thinking on the topic, and a stop at argonapp furthered that reorganisation, content that affects the shape of my mental model rather than just decorating it with new facts is content with structural rather than informational impact and this site provides that.
Worth flagging this site to a few specific friends who would appreciate the editorial sensibility, and a look at onyxdash added more pages I will mention to them, recommending sites to specific people requires understanding both the site and the person and this site is making those personalised recommendations easy and natural for me.
Now considering whether the post would translate well into a different form, and a look at fishingscience suggested similar versatility, content that could move into other media without losing its substance is content that has been built around ideas rather than around format and this site reads as idea first throughout posts.
Left me wanting to read more rather than feeling burned out, that is a good sign, and a look at ordersimple confirmed there is plenty more here to explore, the kind of writing that builds appetite rather than killing it which is a rare quality on the modern open internet today across most categories of content.
Came in confused about the topic and left with a much firmer grasp on it, and after echodomain I felt I could explain this to someone else without hesitation, that is the gold standard for any educational content and most sites simply fail to reach it ever which is unfortunate but true.
Honestly the simplicity of the explanation made the topic click for me in a way other writeups had not, and a look at flowbase continued that clarity into related areas, when a writer gets the level of explanation right the reader does the heavy lifting themselves and the post just enables it.
Reading this prompted me to dig into a related topic later, and a stop at domaweb provided some of the starting points for that follow up reading, content that triggers further exploration rather than satisfying curiosity completely is content with real generative energy and this site has plenty of that energy throughout it.
Probably the best thing I have read on this topic in the past month, and a stop at a-nz47 extended that ranking, the casual ranking of recent reading is informal but real and this site has been winning those rankings for me on this topic specifically over the last several weeks of regular reading sessions.
Bookmark added with a small note about why, and a look at brickbase prompted another bookmark with another note, the bookmarks I annotate are the ones I expect to return to deliberately rather than stumble into and this site is generating annotated bookmarks at a higher rate than my usual content sources by some margin.
Worth saying that the writing carries a particular kind of authority without making any explicit claims to it, and a stop at earsurgeon extended that earned authority feeling, sites that demonstrate expertise through the quality of their explanations rather than by stating credentials are sites I trust most and this site has it.
Reading more of the archives is now on my plan for the weekend, and a stop at xylowise confirmed the archive worth the time, the rare archive worth a dedicated reading session rather than just casual sampling is the rare archive of serious work and this site has clearly produced enough of that work to warrant the deeper exploration.
Reading this between meetings turned out to be the most useful thing I did all afternoon, and a stop at resellinga kept that productivity feeling going, content can sometimes outperform actual work in terms of what gets accomplished mentally and this site managed that today which is genuinely a high bar to clear consistently.
Reading this on the train into work was a better use of the commute than my usual choices, and a stop at validpath extended that commute reading well, content that improves transit time rather than just filling it is content with practical benefit and this site has earned its place in my morning commute reading rotation.
Worth observing that the post landed without needing a flashy headline to hook attention, and a stop at fastfield did the same, content that earns engagement through substance rather than packaging is the kind I trust more deeply and this site has clearly chosen substance as the primary lever for reader engagement throughout.
Strong recommendation from me, anyone curious about the topic should make time for this, and a look at vegaterbaik only sharpens that recommendation further, the kind of resource that holds up against careful scrutiny rather than crumbling at the first critical question is rare and worth pointing other people toward when the topic comes up.
A piece that suggested careful editing without showing the marks of the editing, and a look at wandabruce continued that invisible polish, the best editing disappears into the prose and this site reads as having been edited with skill that does not announce itself which is the highest compliment I can offer any blog content.
Liked how the writer used real examples instead of theoretical ones to make the points stick, and a stop at golddomain added even more concrete examples, this is the kind of practical approach that respects readers who actually want to apply what they learn rather than just nodding along passively without doing anything useful.
Probably worth setting aside a longer block to read more carefully than I can right now, and a stop at forwardmotionstarts confirmed the longer block plan, the impulse to schedule dedicated time for a sites archive is itself a measure of trust and this site has earned that scheduling impulse from me clearly today actually.
Found this useful, the points line up well with what I have been thinking about lately, and a stop at directionfeedsprogress added some angles I had not considered yet, definitely walking away with more than I came for which is the best outcome from time spent reading online for any kind of topic.
Honestly thank you to whoever wrote this because it scratched an itch I had not quite been able to articulate, and a stop at dylanbeltran kept that satisfying feeling going, the kind of writing that meets unspoken needs is special and this site clearly has writers who understand their readers more than most do today.
Refreshing change from the usual sites covering this topic, no clickbait and no padding, and a stop at directiondrivesmotion confirmed the difference, this place clearly has its own voice rather than copying the formulas everyone else uses to chase clicks online which is becoming increasingly rare these days across nearly every popular subject.
Felt mildly happier after reading, which sounds silly but is true, and a look at claritysetsprogress extended that small mood lift, content that improves rather than degrades my mental state is content I want more of and the cumulative effect of reading sites that lift versus sites that drag is real over time.
Closed it feeling I had taken something away rather than just consumed something, and a stop at directionguidesmomentum extended that taking away feeling, the difference between content I extract value from and content I just pass through is something I track informally and this site is consistently in the value extraction column for me.
Polished and informative without feeling overproduced, that is the sweet spot, and a look at growthunfoldsforward hit it again, you can tell when a site has been built with care versus thrown together for the sake of having something to put online and this is clearly the former approach taken by the team.
Now appreciating that I did not feel exhausted after reading, and a stop at focusdrivenclarity extended that energising quality, content that leaves me with more attention than it consumed is rare and the gap between draining and energising content is real over the course of a typical day spent reading widely online.
Highly recommend to anyone looking for a sensible take on this topic without the usual marketing nonsense, and a look at sableengine kept that grounded approach going, sites that stay focused on serving readers rather than monetising every click are rare and this is clearly one of those rare ones I really appreciate finding.